About Us
An Independent Agency, on Purpose
The Comstock Agency isn’t tied to one insurance company. We work for the family on the other end of the call, and we shop their coverage across 30+ carriers before we recommend anything.
Why Independent Matters
A captive agent sells one company’s policies, so every family gets that company’s answer. An independent agent is appointed with many carriers, and each of them prices health, age and budget a little differently. One is kinder to blood pressure, another to a past diagnosis, another to someone who quit smoking a few years ago. Same person, meaningfully different prices.
We shop 30+ carriers, and the agency is part of an established national insurance organization, which gives us the carriers, the training and the back office, and leaves the judgment where it belongs: with you, on the phone.
It isn’t a product. It’s a promise somebody made to their family, and our job is to make sure the promise holds.
How We Work
Everything starts with a conversation, by phone or video. Your agent asks about the house, the people who depend on you, your budget and your health, because those are the questions the carriers ask, and you should hear them from us first.
Then we shop it. Same answers, every carrier. You get two or three real options and the trade-offs said plainly, including the one where the right answer is to wait, or to buy less than you thought. If it isn’t a fit, we’ll tell you.
Every policy we recommend has to pass two tests. It fits your budget, and it meets the need you’re buying it for. Both, not one: coverage you can’t keep paying for lapses, and a cheap policy that doesn’t do the job is money spent on nothing.
Once you choose, your agent handles the application, stays on it through underwriting, and answers when something changes later. No call center.
Your Agent
Josh Comstock, Licensed Independent Life Insurance Agent.
Josh spent two decades in web development and design—building online and print presences for small businesses and organizations, mostly the kind where the owner still answers the phone. In 2012, he married Sharla, and they moved to North Idaho. In 2022, he changed lanes, studied for his Life and Health license, and has been at it since: sitting down with families and working out what happens to the house, and the people in it, on the worst day of their lives. That’s the whole job. He and Sharla live in beautiful Sandpoint, Idaho, where they’re active members of their church. Most weekends they’re outside somewhere—up a mountain, down to a lake, or hauling a trailer with their ATV down some forest service road—usually with their friends on an adventure.
National Producer Number 20322158. How to verify a license.
A Few Photos









Request a Quick Quote
A minute of answers, then a licensed agent calls with your options, usually within one business day. No health history here; that part is a conversation.
Two Tests Every Policy Has to Pass
- It fits your budget. A premium you can carry this year and in ten.
- It meets the need. Enough coverage, of the right kind, to do the job you’re buying it for.
An option that passes only one isn’t one we’ll recommend.
A licensed agent places coverage with insurance carriers; The Comstock Agency does not underwrite or issue policies. Insurance products are offered only in the states where the agency and its agents are licensed.